Hypothetical - Zimbabwe A vs India A
- brmtaylor.com admin
- Administrator
- Posts: 7924
- Joined: Wed Nov 28, 2007 3:22 pm
- Contact:
Hypothetical - Zimbabwe A vs India A
Imagine before the tour of Sri Lanka this year, Zimbabwe were given two 4-day FC matches against India - played in India.
Who would you play in the games against India A? The first choice Test XI, the A team or a combination?
I think it would be good to play a combination to give guys experience in sub-continental conditions ahead of SL but also to give quality non-Test game time to emerging players.
SL Test Squad: Mawoyo, H Masakadza, Burl, Musakanda, Raza, Moor, Cremer, Mumba, Chatara, C Ervine, S Williams, R Chakabva, Tiripano, Chisoro, Mpofu
A Team (only): Mire, Ngarava, W Masakadza
Game 1
1. T Mawoyo
2. H Masakadza
3. R Burl
4. T Musakanda
5. S Raza
6. S Mire
7. PJ Moor (wk)
8. G Cremer (c)
9. C Mumba
10. W Masakadza
11. T Chatara
Game 2
1. T Mawoyo
2. R Burl
3. C Ervine
4. T Musakanda
5. S Williams
6. S Mire
7. R Chakabva (wk)
8. G Cremer (c)
9. D Tiripano
10. T Chisoro
11. R Ngarava
----
Possible SL Test XI:
1. T Mawoyo
2. R Burl
3. H Masakadza
4. C Ervine
5. S Williams
6. S Raza
7. PJ Moor (wk)
8. G Cremer (c)
9. D Tiripano
10. T Chisoro
11. T Chatara
Who would you play in the games against India A? The first choice Test XI, the A team or a combination?
I think it would be good to play a combination to give guys experience in sub-continental conditions ahead of SL but also to give quality non-Test game time to emerging players.
SL Test Squad: Mawoyo, H Masakadza, Burl, Musakanda, Raza, Moor, Cremer, Mumba, Chatara, C Ervine, S Williams, R Chakabva, Tiripano, Chisoro, Mpofu
A Team (only): Mire, Ngarava, W Masakadza
Game 1
1. T Mawoyo
2. H Masakadza
3. R Burl
4. T Musakanda
5. S Raza
6. S Mire
7. PJ Moor (wk)
8. G Cremer (c)
9. C Mumba
10. W Masakadza
11. T Chatara
Game 2
1. T Mawoyo
2. R Burl
3. C Ervine
4. T Musakanda
5. S Williams
6. S Mire
7. R Chakabva (wk)
8. G Cremer (c)
9. D Tiripano
10. T Chisoro
11. R Ngarava
----
Possible SL Test XI:
1. T Mawoyo
2. R Burl
3. H Masakadza
4. C Ervine
5. S Williams
6. S Raza
7. PJ Moor (wk)
8. G Cremer (c)
9. D Tiripano
10. T Chisoro
11. T Chatara
-
- Posts: 7037
- Joined: Sat Nov 07, 2009 8:41 am
Re: Hypothetical - Zimbabwe A vs India A
Ngarava over Tiripano for sure. The seamer depth chart ought to be
Chatara/Mumba
Ngarava
Panyangara
Mpofu
Tiripano/Madziva
The first 3 would make a pretty solid attack and Panyangara is an excellent 3rd or 4th seamer. Quality drops off substantially after the top 4.
Chatara/Mumba
Ngarava
Panyangara
Mpofu
Tiripano/Madziva
The first 3 would make a pretty solid attack and Panyangara is an excellent 3rd or 4th seamer. Quality drops off substantially after the top 4.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JjtuZBykSzM (Noreaga - Blood Money Part 3)
Re: Hypothetical - Zimbabwe A vs India A
Can't afford to play Mpofu, Chatara and Ngarava in the same test side due to their shit house batting .....
Chairman of the Neville Madziva fan Club
Originator of the #mumbamania movement
Originator of the #mumbamania movement
-
- Posts: 7037
- Joined: Sat Nov 07, 2009 8:41 am
Re: Hypothetical - Zimbabwe A vs India A
Anything you can get from the 8 down should be a bonus in the Test side. LOIs I can see the need to have bowlers who can bat a bit. The top 7 need to score 90% of runs every time otherwise you're in trouble. You've got to pick your best bowlers for the Test team regardless of their batting ability.jaybro wrote:Can't afford to play Mpofu, Chatara and Ngarava in the same test side due to their shit house batting .....
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JjtuZBykSzM (Noreaga - Blood Money Part 3)
Re: Hypothetical - Zimbabwe A vs India A
Zimbabwe have relied too much on Tiripano' batting recently to disregard it .....
Chairman of the Neville Madziva fan Club
Originator of the #mumbamania movement
Originator of the #mumbamania movement
-
- Posts: 2025
- Joined: Tue Jan 01, 2008 9:35 am
- Supports: MidWest Rhinos
- Location: Sussex
Re: Hypothetical - Zimbabwe A vs India A
If Zimbabwe are to make any progress towards being a decent side and meriting their place against the other test playing nations, then a 15/18 man squad needs to be picked and stuck to like glue, no messing around, no bringing back players from the past and no deviation from that squad in any fixtures against any opposition
Re: Hypothetical - Zimbabwe A vs India A
I vote for option D (which you don't have):
The entire Zimbabwean test XI AND some A team players.
How so?
Well you have TWO four-day first class matches against India A. In India.
Absolutely no reason you couldn't have the entire Zimababwean Test squad of 14-15 play over the 2 matches with some A team players mixed in.
Match 1 could see 5 of the first pick test XI + 3 of the test reserves + 3 A team players
Match 2 could see 6 of the first pick test XI + 1 of the test reserves + 4 A team players
Thus every test player gets at least 1 match against India A and between 4-7 A team players could also get a chance to play.
The entire Zimbabwean test XI AND some A team players.
How so?
Well you have TWO four-day first class matches against India A. In India.
Absolutely no reason you couldn't have the entire Zimababwean Test squad of 14-15 play over the 2 matches with some A team players mixed in.
Match 1 could see 5 of the first pick test XI + 3 of the test reserves + 3 A team players
Match 2 could see 6 of the first pick test XI + 1 of the test reserves + 4 A team players
Thus every test player gets at least 1 match against India A and between 4-7 A team players could also get a chance to play.
Re: Hypothetical - Zimbabwe A vs India A
Can we pick 22 guys in our XI, that way we might get to three figures.
Neil Johnson, Alistair Campbell, Murray Goodwin, Andy Flower (w), Grant Flower, Dave Houghton, Guy Whittall, Heath Streak (c), Andy Blignaut, Ray Price, Eddo Brandes
-
- Posts: 1716
- Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2008 1:26 pm
Re: Hypothetical - Zimbabwe A vs India A
Get 22 in the team !eugene wrote:Can we pick 22 guys in our XI, that way we might get to three figures.
Re: Hypothetical - Zimbabwe A vs India A
Too bad I can't name 22 Zimbabwean cricketers I actually think deserve selection.
Neil Johnson, Alistair Campbell, Murray Goodwin, Andy Flower (w), Grant Flower, Dave Houghton, Guy Whittall, Heath Streak (c), Andy Blignaut, Ray Price, Eddo Brandes