Stuart MacGill says Aus A should not be touring Zim

[CrimsonAvenger]

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/ ... 6031539930

Stuart MacGill, who abandoned a 2004 tour of Zimbabwe on ethical grounds, said the volatile political climate under dictator Robert Mugabe had not changed and it was absurd an Australia A team, which features young players Tim Paine, Phillip Hughes and David Warner, were being put in this position.

Last week, Cricket Australia short-listed a squad of 24 players to tour Zimbabwe later this year.

Cricket Australia spokesman Peter Young said he was yet to hear of any complaints or concerns from the short list.

However, Federal Government website Smart Traveller this week warned Australians from touring Zimbabwe because of extreme danger.

"We advise you to re-consider your need to travel to Zimbabwe at this time due to politically-motivated violence in some rural areas, the high level of criminal activity, the absence of the rule of law, and the poor economic conditions which could lead to civil unrest, " the government warned.

MacGill said nothing had changed since the Aussies last pulled out of a trip to Zimbabwe.

"Maybe there have been far-higher profile issues around the globe over the last couple of years, and certainly the past couple of weeks [civil unrest in Libya] but the fact remains that the money generated by the Zimbabwean Cricket Union contributes to the Mugabe regime, " MacGill said.

"It's a clear-cut case in my opinion, and I would immediately suggest that Australia A are simply a bartering tool so the main team doesn't have to travel. The cynic in me feels Australia A are going because Cricket Australia thinks they will fly under the radar."

Young said the tour of Zimbabwe had been public knowledge for a few months.

"We also had the Zimbabwe government minister for sport [David Coltart] come to Australia and New Zealand about a year ago and he made a high-profile appeal for the sporting links to be retained, " Young said.

"He saw a real positive human-rights impact from doing that in terms of crickets development."

MacGill said young players with a dream of featuring in the first XI would never let anything stand in their way.

"I was 35 when I made the decision not to tour and was prepared for any outcome [from Cricket Australia], but you couldn't blame a 20-year-old for doing anything to play for his country, " MacGill said.

"You can't blame the players, but I definitely feel strongly about Cricket Australia putting them in this position."

[aydee]

the fact remains that the money generated by the Zimbabwean Cricket Union contributes to the Mugabe regime, " MacGill said.

This is not a fact. This is hearsay, that has never been proven. The Zimbabwe Cricket Union hasn't existed for years. How much profit would the ZCU/ZC be making that they could plow back into political activity in any case? It worries me that these stroies keep cropping up, because people will believe them.

Would David Coltart be involved if there was any chance that by supporting ZC he was aiding Mugabe financially? Ridiculous.

[eugene]

It is interesting that playing Zimbabwe now seems to be a non-issue when politically little has changed. Mugabe is still in power, there is little freedom of press, and the unity government is a joke on the verge of collapse. Once election season begins in Zimbabwe and the political violence returns I think the Zimbabwe issue will rear its ugly head again.

[aydee]

It is interesting that playing Zimbabwe now seems to be a non-issue when politically little has changed. Mugabe is still in power, there is little freedom of press, and the unity government is a joke on the verge of collapse. Once election season begins in Zimbabwe and the political violence returns I think the Zimbabwe issue will rear its ugly head again.

True.

I just think it's a shame that the cricket should have to be tarninshed, when there is no evidence of a link between cricket and political violence.

[eugene]

Indeed. While Mugabe does like cricket I don't think he is using it as a tool for oppression. I guess it comes down to if other countries want to associate with Zimbabwe on any level and if they feel that sport and politics are connected.

[aydee]

Indeed. While Mugabe does like cricket I don't think he is using it as a tool for oppression. I guess it comes down to if other countries want to associate with Zimbabwe on any level and if they feel that sport and politics are connected.

Really, all they would be doing is denying countless young hopefulls, like Tendai Chatara, etc, the chance to make a good honest living, in a country where that is not always that easy. Sad.

[hhm]

.... the fact remains that the money generated by the Zimbabwean Cricket Union contributes to the Mugabe regime, " MacGill said. .... "It's a clear-cut case in my opinion, and I would immediately suggest that Australia A are simply a bartering tool so the main team doesn't have to travel. The cynic in me feels Australia A are going because Cricket Australia thinks they will fly under the radar."....I definitely feel strongly about Cricket Australia putting them in this position."

Prick!

[eugene]

Do we know for sure that money generated from cricket isn't funding ZANU-PF somewhere along the way. I have seen no evidence that it does but it also hard to disprove. Stuart MacGill is a classy guy and I always respected him for his choice to not tour Zimbabwe when the situationwas far worse than it is now.

[clikcspeed]

We really need this tour to happen, thats all I can say.

[Zimfanatic69]

We really need this tour to happen, thats all I can say.

So we can be hammered by an innings in every 4 day game, and pummelled in the one dayers.

No one will learn from that.