Page 1 of 3
Ireland pre Tour
Posted: Wed Jan 22, 2025 2:04 am
by Andy31
Never to early for a pre tour thread.
I'm Hoping for at least Munyonga, Campbell and N.Welch to get a crack at some stage.
The next round of matches will be a big factor.
Bowling wise.
I feel we have a core group that they will stick with.
I assume his injured but Tinashe Muchawaya was hoping would take the step up and see at some point.
My pick for surprise/head scratcher selection will be Bawa
Re: Ireland pre Tour
Posted: Wed Jan 22, 2025 8:03 am
by tawac
Looking at the test set up I think form should be a big factor in selection. But we all know the selectors always have a mind of their own. N Welch has done more than enough for his name to be in the conversation. Nyasha Mavayo should also be looking to get a look in with Gumbie's form being really out of sorts.
Muchawaya's form took a deep after some great performance last year. He really seems to have fallen out of favour at Mountaineers.
Re: Ireland pre Tour
Posted: Wed Jan 22, 2025 9:14 am
by zimfan1
Raza and Blessing must be in doubt for the test. ILT20 does not finish until after the test has started.
Re: Ireland pre Tour
Posted: Wed Jan 22, 2025 9:45 am
by Andy31
Surely atleast Blessing would be back?
Re: Ireland pre Tour
Posted: Wed Jan 22, 2025 10:24 am
by aydee
Andy31 wrote: āWed Jan 22, 2025 9:45 am
Surely atleast Blessing would be back?
Would be extremely disappointed if he isn't.
Re: Ireland pre Tour
Posted: Wed Jan 22, 2025 4:54 pm
by Kriterion_BD
Good thread/discussion. I think the Test is first so I'll just talk about that. I'll pick my XI and try to justify the picks:
1) Gumbie - he was everyone's favorite prior to the Afghan series, harsh to drop him after just 1 bad series, ideally he should get the Ireland Test + one more before being dropped. He's limited but also has a pretty compact technique.
2) Curran - exceeded all expectations. Should be the mainstay here for a while.
3) Ervine - has form on his side, but he's a bit too susceptible to edging outwardly moving balls behind to bat at 3, but he does have form and very few others do
4) Williams - also has form, and you have to bat your two best batters at 3/4
5) Myers - out of form, but perhaps pushing him down to the middle might make things a bit easier. Easily the most talented young black batter so you have to stick with him.
6) Bennett - has done well enough across formats to be a sure-fire starter in each.
7) Mayavo - is he a keeper? You need a keeper and Gumbie can't do it and open. Also not sold on Madande's batting and his WK is abject.
8) Mavuta - a wrist spinner who can bat...should get at least another chance.
9) Ngarava - no need to write much about Richie and Blessing
10) Muzarabani
11) Nyamhuri - Showed enough promise to get more caps
Re: Ireland pre Tour
Posted: Wed Jan 22, 2025 7:35 pm
by Pat_Bee
Iād get wez in I think, peaking at the right time.
Re: Ireland pre Tour
Posted: Wed Jan 22, 2025 9:12 pm
by ZIMDOGGY
Kriterion_BD wrote: āWed Jan 22, 2025 4:54 pm
Good thread/discussion. I think the Test is first so I'll just talk about that. I'll pick my XI and try to justify the picks:
1) Gumbie - he was everyone's favorite prior to the Afghan series, harsh to drop him after just 1 bad series, ideally he should get the Ireland Test + one more before being dropped. He's limited but also has a pretty compact technique.
2) Curran - exceeded all expectations. Should be the mainstay here for a while.
3) Ervine - has form on his side, but he's a bit too susceptible to edging outwardly moving balls behind to bat at 3, but he does have form and very few others do
4) Williams - also has form, and you have to bat your two best batters at 3/4
5) Myers - out of form, but perhaps pushing him down to the middle might make things a bit easier. Easily the most talented young black batter so you have to stick with him.
6) Bennett - has done well enough across formats to be a sure-fire starter in each.
7) Mayavo - is he a keeper? You need a keeper and Gumbie can't do it and open. Also not sold on Madande's batting and his WK is abject.
8) Mavuta - a wrist spinner who can bat...should get at least another chance.
9) Ngarava - no need to write much about Richie and Blessing
10) Muzarabani
11) Nyamhuri - Showed enough promise to get more caps
So your solution to win is to replace Raza and Kaitano with Navayo and Mavuta.
Mutendara dat you?
Re: Ireland pre Tour
Posted: Wed Jan 22, 2025 10:04 pm
by mnelson68
Kriterion_BD wrote: āWed Jan 22, 2025 4:54 pm
Good thread/discussion. I think the Test is first so I'll just talk about that. I'll pick my XI and try to justify the picks:
1) Gumbie - he was everyone's favorite prior to the Afghan series, harsh to drop him after just 1 bad series, ideally he should get the Ireland Test + one more before being dropped. He's limited but also has a pretty compact technique.
2) Curran - exceeded all expectations. Should be the mainstay here for a while.
3) Ervine - has form on his side, but he's a bit too susceptible to edging outwardly moving balls behind to bat at 3, but he does have form and very few others do
4) Williams - also has form, and you have to bat your two best batters at 3/4
5) Myers - out of form, but perhaps pushing him down to the middle might make things a bit easier. Easily the most talented young black batter so you have to stick with him.
6) Bennett - has done well enough across formats to be a sure-fire starter in each.
7) Mayavo - is he a keeper? You need a keeper and Gumbie can't do it and open. Also not sold on Madande's batting and his WK is abject.
8) Mavuta - a wrist spinner who can bat...should get at least another chance.
9) Ngarava - no need to write much about Richie and Blessing
10) Muzarabani
11) Nyamhuri - Showed enough promise to get more caps
Must have N.Welch in , Gumbie out and J.Campbell in for Mavuta who isn't any better than the part timers so better batting depth.
Re: Ireland pre Tour
Posted: Thu Jan 23, 2025 12:37 am
by Andy31
I think Gumbie will want to have a very decent next round of domestic.
It be great if their was a warm up game against Ireland. A Zim A game.