Page 1 of 1

‘Utseya witchhunted’

Posted: Sat Aug 29, 2009 8:20 pm
by zimfan1
‘Utseya witchhunted’

By Tinashe Kusema

NATIONAL cricket coach Walter Chawaguta has refused to be fazed by mounting criticism levelled against Prosper Utseya’s continued captaincy, describing it as an “unwarranted witch-hunt”.

Questions of Utseya’s ability to lead the national team have been subject to debate following a string of poor results over the past few years with the latest being the embarrassing 1-4 series defeat to Bangladesh a fortnight ago.
Critics have been unanimous in pointing the finger at skipper Utseya, highlighting his poor decision-making, indifferent persona on the field and inability to read the game.
Chawaguta, however, said despite the disappointment of losing the series to the their Asian counterparts, he believed that Utseya was not to blame for the entire result as each player had a part in all the defeats.
“A captain is only as good as his team and in that regard I think it’s not right to blame Prosper for the bad form the team has exhibited over the past couple of years and in particular during the Bangladesh tour. There are a number of reasons why we lost to Bangladesh and none of them had anything to do with the captain as an individual” said Chawaguta.
He went on to defend Utseya for all the criticism that the captain has been receiving particularly from sections of the media and analysts.
“I will have to admit that Prosper is not the most animated person on the field of play as has been stated by most of his critics, but I think that is a merit since he remains level-headed in all situations as he never shows his emotions.
“He is by far the best man for the job at the moment as I have personally witnessed his growth on and off the field the past few years he has been captain. He is the first man to the pitch before practice and the last man off as testified by his improvement in all aspects of the game particularly batting. ”
When asked on some of the reasons for the defeat, Chawaguta pointed to the failure of the batsmen to perform, fingering Chamunorwa Chibhabha as among the culprits who contributed to the defeat of the hosts by Bangladesh.
“Going into the series, we sat down and came up with a game plan in which we would concentrate on the batting. As the Queens wicket is predominately batter friendly we decided to go in with seven batters, two seamers and two spinners.
“In the first two ODIs, Chibhabha, as an all-ounder, was an integral part of this strategy providing cover in both the bowling (seamers) and batting, but when he did not perform we had to adapt and reshuffle the players.
“This is not to say that he was solely responsible for the loss but he and the other batsmen did not do their jobs, falling short of our four centuries target we had set for them from the onset.
“The whole team did not help themselves with their fielding which was pathetic to say the least. We spent most of the time prior to the series going through the basics and they went on to do the opposite dropping crucial catches that could have changed the complexion of the match in all our defeats,” went on the gaffer.
As the country now goes through the wreckage of their disappointing series, they will have to go back to the drawing board and come up with new strategies, as they seek to recover lost pride when they tour Bangladesh again in mid October.
Chawaguta has opted to remain optimistic, relying on some of the positives from the recent series.
“At the moment we have decided to put the past series behind us and concentrate on the upcoming tour to Bangladesh again, after the Champions Trophy.
“With the coming on board of Heath Streak, as the bowling coach, and some new faces we have been looking at, we expect to fare much better against the Asians and hopefully win this time” said Chawaguta.
Admire Manyumwa, Trevor Garwe and Christopher Mpofu are among some of the faces expected to feature this time around.
The three seamers were dropped during Bangladesh’s visit, as the Queens wicket was not pace-friendly.
They featured in the ICC Intercontinental Cup match against Afghanistan in Mutare with Garwe scoring his maiden century to rescue the hosts from defeat.
The match ended in a draw.
http://www.sundaymail.co.zw/inside.aspx ... 336&cat=18

Re: ‘Utseya witchhunted’

Posted: Sat Aug 29, 2009 8:23 pm
by zimfan1
zimfan1 wrote:
When asked on some of the reasons for the defeat, Chawaguta pointed to the failure of the batsmen to perform, fingering Chamunorwa Chibhabha as among the culprits who contributed to the defeat of the hosts by Bangladesh.
“Going into the series, we sat down and came up with a game plan in which we would concentrate on the batting. As the Queens wicket is predominately batter friendly we decided to go in with seven batters, two seamers and two spinners.
“In the first two ODIs, Chibhabha, as an all-ounder, was an integral part of this strategy providing cover in both the bowling (seamers) and batting, but when he did not perform we had to adapt and reshuffle the players.
.

Yes blame it all on Chibhabha, of course it was nothing to do with the fact that bad captaincy decisions were made and the wrong side was selected :D

But on another note looks like there will be no series against the West Indies and no series away against Sri Lanka before November :(

Re: ‘Utseya witchhunted’

Posted: Sat Aug 29, 2009 8:39 pm
by maehara
Most of the criticism of Utseya has been fair & reasoned, I'd say. Yes, there are other players who didn't pull their weight, and you could point fingers at more than Chibhabha if you felt so inclined. But you know what? The side are meant to play to a gameplan drawn up by the coach and implemented on the field by the captain - and against Bangladesh, we didn't appear to have much of a gameplan. Guess whose fault that would be, then...?

Re: ‘Utseya witchhunted’

Posted: Sat Aug 29, 2009 10:08 pm
by eugene
Chawaguta is a man under pressure, both he and Utseya should go.

Re: ‘Utseya witchhunted’

Posted: Sun Aug 30, 2009 5:57 pm
by Detective RDS
Zimbabwe should try out a new coach-captain combination.

I also agree that Utseya and Chwaguta should go now.

For me Raymond Price should be the captain. He really should be given the honour of his service. Masakadza as a vice captain is okay.

As far as the coaching post is concerned, Zimbabwe needs an experienced, qualified and a more professional coach. Robin Brown is perfectly best suited for this job. Besides him there a lot of capable coaches more than Chwaguta likes of Stephen Mangongo, Andy Waller, Dirk Viljoen etc.

For the upcoming squad, I think Sibanda, Waller and Chibhabha will be dropped from the squad of previous series. Forster Mutizwa will definitely walk in and for the other two places, Mpofu and Manyumwa or Garwe have got good chances.

Re: ‘Utseya witchhunted’

Posted: Sun Aug 30, 2009 6:33 pm
by Tinashce Ruswa
Well the coach bases his decisions on what he sees and Roudy(PRO) has a gift to remain indifferent in many situations, so really that is a plus,alas if game plans go wrong and a series is lost we should aim to rebuild on what is already there and look to chart the way forward.Personally I think captaining a squad like Zim is not a skill one attains over a month or year,chopping and changing the combination might hinder team growth.

Personally I think they should be given more time to develop and learn the tskills of the trade ..asking for the sacking of the team leadership is analogous to the Ozzies seeking Ponting's and the coaches head after and Ashes.

If my memory serves me right all concerned stakeholders said that this was anew beginning for Zimbabwe cricket so lets watch them sprout and grow from seedlings to trees then after that we can make radical decisions.

Re: ‘Utseya witchhunted’

Posted: Sun Aug 30, 2009 6:40 pm
by Tinashce Ruswa
coz if i am not mistaken you have only one month before the next series...that time shud be used to analize and strategize on how to play better and win against Bangladesh emphasis on technical analysis and condition analysis