Ranking Zimbabwe's Match-Winners

[eugene]

Not to mention our dismal opening stands mean the middle order are pretty much opening anyway. You always play your best batsmen at 3-5 which Zimbabwe follows.

[pariah]

Sarcasm and invective - the standard modus operandi of deflection!

Kriterion opemed this thread purely to debunk one of my "facts". He swiftly realised that it was not possible in this particular case. Not to be dissuaded, he gave it several more stabs again, and with great supoort I must add. Six pages later it still hasn't worked out!

Safe to say the thread has outlived its usefulness.

[Kriterion_BD]

Sarcasm and invective - the standard modus operandi of deflection!

Kriterion opemed this thread purely to debunk one of my "facts". He swiftly realised that it was not possible in this particular case. Not to be dissuaded, he gave it several more stabs again, and with great supoort I must add. Six pages later it still hasn't worked out!

Safe to say the thread has outlived its usefulness.

except that I rest my case having shown that Hamilton is only marginally better than Ashraful as match winner, 2.2% to 1.7% of innings. Ie once every 50 innings they will put in a match winning performance. But Hammy is better than Williams and somehow better that Taylor. But behind Ervine and Cremer and Chatara who are all between 3.6 and 5.1%.

But you have a guy like Shakib who is in at around 17% and Tamim in at around 10%. My guess would be guys like Kohli, Smith, Williamson, Starc are probably around 25-30%, or one in every 3rd innings they win matches for their team.

Now here is the challenge for you if you dont like my study: give me parameters you find agreeable for match-winning performances. I guarantee you Hamilton will not turn into a Kohli even if he hides at #6 in the batting order. but why dont we run the numbers and find out? ball is in your court. i provided my study, you can provide yours if you think yours are better. are you as confident as I am?

Many of your notions defy common sense and dont stand up facts.

[eugene]

Good to see Shakib showing himself to be a matchwinner against Australia.